11
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond – Sinnoh Reimagined with Charm
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond faithfully remakes the classic Sinnoh region with quality-of-life improvements, though controversial visual style divides critics. Rating: 7.3/10.
Game Info
Verdict
Faithful Sinnoh remake with exceptional stability and quality-of-life improvements; controversial chibi aesthetics and missing Pokémon Platinum content limit broader appeal.
Pros
- Flawless 30fps performance on all Switch models with zero frame drops
- Comprehensive quality-of-life improvements over original (faster experience gain, streamlined menus)
- Charming chibi art style evokes nostalgic handheld-era charm
- Grand Underground redesign enables organic creature diversity
- Pokémon follow trainers overworld, eliminating exploration disconnect
- Super Contest Shows provide non-battle engagement alternative
- Accessible difficulty accommodates casual and new players
- Cynthia postgame battle delivers series' most challenging champion encounter
Cons
- Chibi art direction divides aesthetic opinions; lacks visual sophistication versus Sword
- Omits Pokémon Platinum content (Battle Frontier, expanded Pokédex)
- Linear progression removes player agency versus modern open-world design
- Limited endgame content post-champion battle
- Online-only multiplayer lacks local couch co-op
- Overpriced at $59.99 versus original DS cartridge cost inflation argument
Performance Notes
Rock-solid 30fps lock across all Switch models. Docked and handheld modes maintain identical performance. Minimal load times (2-3 seconds). Chibi art style optimizes performance at cost of graphical fidelity compared to Pokémon Sword.
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond represents the first mainline Pokémon game developed by ILCA rather than Game Freak, resulting in a faithful remake of 2006’s Pokémon Diamond with modernized mechanics. The chibi-style art direction polarizes audiences while streamlined quality-of-life improvements make the experience more accessible than the original DS title. The game trades ambitious innovation for nostalgic comfort, maintaining 30fps stability across all Switch models despite reduced graphical fidelity. This review evaluates whether faithful recreation justifies a $59.99 price tag and examines how the remake compares to the superior Pokémon Platinum that preceded it.
How to Play Pokémon Brilliant Diamond
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond preserves the original Diamond’s structure while introducing contemporary quality-of-life systems. The Sinnoh region unfolds linearly through eight gym challenges, with story progression gated until mandatory benchmarks. Character customization returns, allowing gender-flexible trainers from the start.
- Controls – Joy-Con or Pro Controller fully supported; handheld mode smooth; menu navigation streamlined versus original; no motion control gimmicks.
- Progression – Collect eight gym badges by defeating Gym Leaders in escalating difficulty; face Elite Four then Champion Cynthia; post-game includes Battle Tower rematches and Pokedex completion hunts.
- Combat/Mechanics – Turn-based battles without Dynamax; physical/special split remains; Pokémon follow trainers overworld; physical and terrain interactions simplified versus originals; no affection systems inflating difficulty.
- Tips – Catch early Starly for flying utility; stock Full Heals before Cynthia battle; Sinnoh has limited Fire-type availability; leverage type coverage over levels; exploit Grand Underground Pokémon spawns for team diversity.
Who Should Play Pokémon Brilliant Diamond
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond targets nostalgic veterans craving Sinnoh revisitation and newcomers seeking accessible turn-based RPG comfort. The simplified difficulty and linear progression suit casual players avoiding competitive complexity. Avoid if you demand modern open-world design, exhaustive endgame content, or cutting-edge graphics.
- Pokémon Nostalgists – Faithful recreation of Gen 4 structure; charming art style evokes franchise’s handheld roots; contains every Sinnoh Pokémon alongside legendaries from prior generations via postgame unlocks.
- Casual RPG Newcomers – Forgiving difficulty curve; simple storyline without convoluted plot twists; Grand Underground provides catch-variety without grinding; accommodating for first-time players.
- Completionists – Pokedex encourages systematic exploration; 150+ Pokémon catchable in main story; Secret Base decoration systems add side progression; Super Contest Shows offer alternative engagement.
- Skip if – You prefer open-world exploration over linear narrative; seek challenging endgame like Battle Frontier; dislike chibi art aesthetic; demand 60fps performance or modern graphics.
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond Platform Performance
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond achieves exceptional stability on Switch, maintaining 30fps lock throughout gameplay with no reported frame drops. Resolution remains consistent whether docked or handheld, though visual fidelity is deliberately simplified compared to contemporaries.
| Platform | Resolution | FPS | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Switch Docked | 1080p | 30 | Stable; no fluctuations; chibi aesthetics mask technical limitations. |
| Switch Handheld | 720p | 30 | Identical frame pacing; minimal resolution impact on chibi graphics. |
| Both Modes | Fixed resolution | 30 locked | No dynamic scaling; pure 30fps cap throughout all gameplay scenarios. |
| Load Times | N/A | 2-3 sec | Faster than Sword; minimal wait between transitions and battles. |
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond System Requirements
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond exists exclusively on Nintendo Switch with no planned PC release. Storage requirements are minimal; physical cartridges install with patches automatically. Online functionality requires Nintendo Switch Online for trading and battle features.
| Component | Requirement | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Platform | Nintendo Switch (all models) | OLED, v2, and original v1 perform identically; no performance variance. |
| Storage | 6.858GB | Among smallest Switch games; physical cartridges require patch downloads. |
| Nintendo Switch Online | Required for online features | $4.99/month; enables Global Union Room trading and ranked battles. |
| No DLC | Complete at purchase | Zero post-launch content announced; all legendary Pokémon available in postgame. |
| Controller | One Joy-Con or Pro Controller | Fully playable handheld; no motion control mandatory. |
Similar Games to Pokémon Brilliant Diamond
If Pokémon Brilliant Diamond appeals to you, these titles offer comparable turn-based exploration and creature collection with varied mechanics and settings.
- Pokémon HeartGold/SoulSilver – Predecessor remakes of Gen 2; similar faithful recreation philosophy; DS exclusives now expensive; mechanical depth equivalent to Brilliant Diamond.
- Pokémon Legends: Arceus – Action-oriented departure from turn-based formula; same region-specific charm; real-time catch mechanics; available on Switch; higher critical reception (83/100).
- Temtem – Pokémon spiritual successor with more competitive focus; cross-platform available; MMO elements; similar mechanics with fresh intellectual property.
- Digimon Cyber Sleuth – Monster-catching turn-based RPG with darker narrative; Switch availability; shorter campaign; detective-driven storyline versus Pokémon’s straightforward gym progression.
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond vs Competitors
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond occupies the remake niche within the broader Pokémon franchise. Comparative analysis highlights its preservation approach versus contemporary alternatives offering innovation.
| Feature | Pokémon Brilliant Diamond | Pokémon Sword/Shield | Pokémon Legends: Arceus |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $59.99 | $59.99 | $59.99 |
| Main Story Hours | 21-30 | 25-45 | 18-25 |
| Open World | No (linear) | Yes (Wild Area) | Limited zones |
| Metacritic Score | 73 | 80 | 83 |
| Stable Performance | Yes (30fps lock) | Occasional drops | Dynamic 60fps option |
| DLC Content | None | Yes ($29.99) | None |
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond Story and World
Sinnoh returns as Pokémon’s geographic north, inspired by Japan’s Hokkaido region. The narrative follows a straightforward progression: collect badges, challenge the Pokémon League, confront Team Galactic’s interdimensional scheming. Story pacing feels measured rather than rushed, allowing character relationships to develop organically. Gym Leaders receive personality tweaks versus the original—Maylene exudes confidence, Candice conveys youthful determination. The rematch with Cynthia in postgame escalates dramatically, representing series-best champion difficulty. Pokémon traverse overworld naturally, removing the disconnect between exploration and battling. Regional history ties Sinnoh to Arceus mythology, deepening world-building despite straightforward plot. Legendary encounters feel momentous rather than contrived. Dialogue respects player intelligence while remaining accessible to newcomers.
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond Multiplayer and Online
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond reintroduces the Union Room system split into Local and Global variants. The Local Club enables wireless trades and battles with nearby Switch consoles within physical proximity. The Global Club connects via Nintendo Switch Online ($4.99/month), allowing random or link-code matchmaking for trading partners and battle opponents. Once accessed, Local and Global Rooms remain accessible from the overworld via Y button, removing Pokémon Center gating. Super Contest Shows support multiplayer judging through online connections. Ranked online battles are unavailable; competitive play defaults to player-organized tournaments. The trade system accommodates item exchanges alongside creature swaps, enabling team building collaboration.
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond DLC and Expansions
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond contains no DLC or post-launch expansions. All legendary Pokémon become available postgame through Ramanas Park, a facility housing dimension-hopping encounters. The lack of DLC contrasts sharply with Sword/Shield’s Expansion Pass ($29.99), positioning Brilliant Diamond as a complete standalone package. Free updates addressed minor balance tweaks and online stability throughout 2021-2022, but no new content released. This stance reflects ILCA’s focus on quality completion over incremental monetization, though it also suggests limited postgame endgame ambition versus alternative titles.
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond Community and Support
The Pokémon Brilliant Diamond community congregates on Reddit (/r/PokemonBDSP) with 150k+ members discussing breeding strategies, shiny hunts, and team composition. The community remains active despite the game’s age, with Discord servers facilitating coordinated trades and local tournaments. GameBanana hosts approximately 200 mods enhancing QoL features and visual improvements, though modding remains unofficial. The Pokémon Company publishes balance adjustments and event distributions sporadically; the last major update arrived December 2021. Official competitive support ceased post-launch, though fan communities maintain ranked battle tiers through platforms like Pokémon Showdown. Community discord servers enable friend code sharing and collaborative Pokédex completion.
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond Ratings and Verdict
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond achieves 73/100 on Metacritic, representing the franchise’s first mixed critical reception among mainline titles. Critics appreciated faithful recreation and performance stability while lamenting visual direction and missing Pokémon Platinum content (Battle Frontier). User sentiment remains positive despite review bombing concerns; the game sold 15.06 million copies by December 2022.